Other Writings


The source for many of the works transcribed here is the Early English Books Online (EEBO) project. English books from long ago have been scanned and deposited in EEBO repository. Unfortunately, the EEBO repository is not available to the public, however, many universities subscribe to the project and you may be able to access EEBO from a local university library. I have the privledge of being able to access EEBO through my association with the University of Sydney.

These titles are transcriptions, and therefore, most of the original old English spelling and misprints have been preserved. The titles transcribed here are not in any particular order of significance or merit. Some of these works are by English Puritans, others were written by those who were subscribers to the 1677/89 Baptist Confession of Faith.

 

1597 - A Golden Chaine, or The Description of Thologie, Containing the order of the causes of Salvation and Damnation, according to Gods word" by William Perkins. PDF (1.5Mb)
William Perkins has been called by some, "the father of the Puritan movement in England".

1623 - The Ten Commandments by Edward Elton. PDF (520kb)
Dr Robert Martin (Emmanuel Reformed Baptist Church, WA and Reformed Baptist Seminary) says of Edward Elton. "All the volumes by Elton are of interest to me. What I have read is rich material,"

 

Works by Baptists

A Special Thanks to Dr James M. Renihan of The Institute for Reformed Baptist Studies (www.reformedbaptistinstitute.org) for his assistance in rendering the Greek and Hebrew present in the original text in these works.

1682 - Some Reasons for Separation from the Church of England, and the Unreasonableness of Persecution Upon that Account, Soberly Debted, in a Dialogue between a Conformist, and a Nonconformist (Baptist.) by H(ercules) C(ollins)  On line, PDF (160k), EPUB, MOBI, AZW3.

1684 - A Voice from the Prison or, Meditations on Revelations III. XI. tending to the Establishment of Gods Little Flock, in An Hour of Temptation by Hercules Collins  On line, PDF (230k), EPUB, MOBI, AZW3.

For most of the 17th Century, to be a Baptist was illegal and it was not uncommon for our Baptist forefathers to be imprisoned for their preach or writing.

1691 - Believers Baptism from Heaven, and of Divine Institution. Infants Baptism from Earth, and Human Invention. by Hercules Collins  On line, PDF (340k), EPUB, MOBI, AZW3.

This provides, at least one 17th Century Calvinistic Baptist's view of the Ordinance of Baptism. It also shows some of the common arguments against beleiver's Baptism that were being used at the time and how Collin's addresses them. While Collins does not address the modern covenant theology arguments for infant baptism, his strong biblical arguments still hold true.

1692 - The Life and Death Of That Old Disciple of Jesus Christ, and Eminent Minister of the Gospel Mr. Hanserd Knollys Who Dyed In the Ninety Third Year of his Age.  On line, PDF, EPUB, MOBI, AZW3.

This is Hanserd Knolly's autobiography covering the first seventy years of his life. While it seems, he did write more, it has been last. It was published posthumously by William Kiffin, who added the preface. Attached to this work is Knolly's last letter to the Church he had pastored for nearly 50 years.

At the end of this publication is a list of other titles published by the printer, John Harris. It is historically interesting, cataloging some of the literature circulating at the time. It also deomonstrates the relationship of Knolly's and Benjamin Keach; with Knolly's, as a School-Master, recommending Keach's book, "Instructions for Children".

1692 - Animadversions Upon the Responses of the Athenian Mercury, to the Questions about Infant-Baptism by Hercules Collins. An animadversion is an action or an act of turning the attention to a subject; the observation or consideration of something.Oxford English Dictionary, online.

Download the PDF (129k), EPUB, MOBI, AZW3

The Athenian Mercury published two articles on questions put to them concerning Christian baptism, coming down on the side of infant baptism. Collins, in this article calls attention to these articles and seeks to rebut them. Benjamin Keach also wrote a response to the Athenian Mercury's articles, Pedo-Baptism disproved Being an Answer to Two printed papers (put forth by some Gentlemen Called the Athenian Society, Who pretend to Answer all Questions sent to them of what nature soever) called the Athenian Mercury, One put forth on November 14. the other November. 28, 1691. In which Papers they pretend to answer eight Queries about the lawfulness of Infant-Baptism. Likewise delivers Queries sent to them about the true Subjects of Baptism, &c

Pastor Steve Weavers writes about Keach and Collins' interaction with the Athenian Mercury in his book, G. Stephen Weaver, Jr., Orthodox, Puritan, Baptist: Hercules Collins (1647–1702) and Particular Baptist Identity in Early Modern England (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2015), 58. Available on Amazon .

"During this same period, Keach and Collins would each engage in debate with paedobaptists in the pages of the Athenian Mercury.[1] This periodical was published by a group of scholars known as the Athenian Society which sought to interact with various questions of interest in a public forum.[2] It was edited and published by the London bookseller John Dunton from 1691 to 1697.[3] In 1694, Keach would come to Collins’ defense in print against Gyles Shute in an extended debate about baptism.[4]"

[1]In the November 14, 1691, edition of The Athenian Mercury, the editors replied to questions related to infant baptism, arguing for its validity. Sometime between November 14 and November 28, 1691, Collins responded in print in H. C., Animadversions Upon the Responses of the Athenian Mercury, To the Questions about Infant-Baptism (London, 1691). This work is often listed as having been published in 1692, probably because it has an advertisement for Collins’ Believers-Baptism from Heaven “lately printed,” which is known to have been published in 1691. However, since Collins is responding in his Animadversions to the November 14th issue of the Athenian Mercury and the November 28th issue is a response to Collins’ critique, it had to have been published during the two week window between those two issues.
Benjamin Keach responded to The Athenian Mercury in three separate publications: Pedo-Baptism Disproved (London: John Harris, 1691), The Rector Rectified and Corrected; or, Infant-Baptism Unlawful (London: John Harris, 1692), and An Appendix to the Answer unto Two Athenian Mercuries, Concerning Pedo-Baptism (London: John Harris, 1692).
[2]For a contemporary history of the society, see Charles Gildon, The History of the Athenian Society: For the Resolving of all Nice and Curious Questions (London: James Dowley, 1692).
[3]Berry, Gender, Society and Print, 6. For more on the publishing history of the Athenian Mercury, see Berry, Gender, Society and Print Culture, 18–25.
[4]Benjamin Keach, A Counter-Antidote, To Purge Out the Malignant Effects Of a Late Counterfeit Prepared by Mr. Gyles Shute, An Unskilful Person in Polemical Cures (London: H. Bernard,1694). This work was published in response to Shute’s own Antidote To Prevent the Prevalency of Anabaptism Clearly Vindicated From that Foul Aspersion Of Being A Counterfeit, and the Aspersors Totally Confuted (London: J.R., 1694), which was itself a reply to Collins’ The Antidote Proved A Counterfeit: Or, Error Detected, and Believers Baptism Vindicated (London: William Marshall, 1693). This 1693 work by Collins was, in turn, a response to Gyles Shute’s An Antidote To Prevent the Prelavency of Anabaptism, Or Infants Baptism Vindicated By Way of Query and Answer (London: J.R., 1693). This work by Shute, at first published anonymously, was directed against Collins’ Believers-Baptism from Heaven, and of Divine Institution. Infants-Baptism from Earth, and Human Invention. Proved from the Commission of Christ, the great Law-giver to the Gospel Church (London: J. Hancock, 1691). And this initial work by Collins on the subject was, in part, a rebuttal of Thomas Wall, Baptism Anatomized (London: G. Croom, 1691), and a catechism by Daniel Williams included in his The Vanity of Childhood & Youth, Wherein The Depraved Nature of Young People is Represented, and Means for their Reformation Proposed (London: John Dunton, 1691).


The following articles from Wikipedia and a Blog suggest that one of the Athenian Society, the one designated to addressed theological matters, was Samuel Wesley, the Father of John and Charles.

1693 - The Antidote Proved a Counterfeit Or Error Detected, and Believers Baptism Vindicated Containing An Answer to a Nameless Author's Book, Entituled, An Antidote to prevent the Prevalency of Anabaptism, by Hercules Collins. On line, PDF (188k), EPUB, MOBI, AZW3.

This book is a response to a work called, An Antidote to prevent the Prevalency of Anabaptism or Infants Baptism Vindicated By Way of a Query and Answer: Together with A Few Reflections upon some Remarkable Passages I lately met with in a book intitled, Believers Baptism from Heaven and of Divine Institution: Infants Baptism from Earth and Humane Invention. Which is itself was a rebuttal of Collin's earlier work recently transcribed and available here. The Antidote to Prevent the Prevalency of Anabaptism is published as being written by H.C. of Wapping. Which is an attempt to insinuate that Hercules Collins recanted and published against his own work, Believers Baptism from Heaven. This is why, the title of this new work by Collins is The Antidote Proved a Counterfeit. Unfortunately, in EEBO, the Antidote to Prevent the Prevalency of Anabaptism is wrongfully attributed to Hercules Collins. A list of Collin's genuine works can be found at https://herculescollins.com/works-of-hercules-collins/.

Many arguments used in The Antidote Proved a Counterfeit are similar to those in Believers Baptism from Heaven. However,in this latter work Collins more directly demonstrates why Infants In-covenanting, and the priviledges Children once had with their Parents, repealed, or why the argument of Christian Baptism being based upon circumcision and a covenant theology associated with it is false. He also addresses the matter of Infants being baptised based upon what he opposing authors calls "Habitual Faith".

1695 - The Sandy Foundation of Infant Baptism Shaken: or, An Answer to a Book, Entituled Vindicić Fśderis, Published by Mr. Mence, by Hercules Collins.

The title page explains; "Whose Arguments have been weighed in the Ballance of the Sanctuary, and found too light to prove all the Children of Believers in the Covenant of Grace: And on the contrary demonstrating, that none but the Elect, and all true Believers are in that Covenant".

The preface to this book is by Richard Claridge, who also supplies an Appendix, containing, I. The Pedigree of Infants Habitual Faith. 2. The Judgment of Learned Men against it. Collins also includes; a full Answer to Mr. Michael Harrison of P's P. his Book, Entituled Infant Baptism God’s Ordinance. Together with a Narrative, which contains the Foundation of the Controversie.

Many of the themes in Believers Baptism from Heaven and The Antidote Proved a Counterfeit are repeated and expanded in this later work.

This text was transcribed from PDF files downloaded from and used with the kind permission of the Angus Library and Archive, Regent’s Park College, Oxford (see Angus Treasures).

Read the On line version, or download the PDF (371k), EPUB, MOBI, AZW3

1695 - Truth And Innocency Vindicated or, An Impartial Account of the late Proceedings between Mr. Mence and Mr. Collins,concerning the Salvation of Infants by the Imputation of Christ's Righteousness. Intended for the Information and Satisfaction of the Godly about Wapping, or elsewhere. by Hercules Collins.

This is a short companion work to The Sandy Foudation of Infant Baptism Shaken. IT is Collins' account of the prceedings between himelf and Mr Mence over misinterpreted statments he made in his book, Believers Baptism from Heaven. Beccause of Mr Mence's writing and preach on this matter, in the town of Wapping in which it appears both men lived,, Collins seems to have been maligned and the general populace would quip him as he walked down the street saying, "There goeth Mr. Collins,who holds the Damnation of Infants". In this work Collins sets out the proceedings and the interactions between he and Mr Mence on this matter, so that all the town would know that he was not the antagonist in this intercahnge.

This text was transcribed from PDF files downloaded from and used with the kind permission of the Angus Library and Archive, Regent’s Park College, Oxford (see Angus Treasures).

Download the PDF (99k), EPUB, MOBI, AZW3

 

The Singing in Worship Controversy

The following writings are from a controversy that arose among the Calvinistic Baptists in the late 1600s which related to the introduction of congregational singing in worship services. Today we might find such a controversy strange. However, we should seek to learn lessons from the past. This controversy raises questions that need to be addressed in all debates of this nature, such as: is this a matter of doctrine or indifference? Is there a truly Biblical basis for this practice? How should we conduct ourselves towards brothers with an opposite view on the matter?

1691 - An Answer To A Brief Discourse Concerning Singing In the Publick Worship of God In The Gospel-Church, By I.M in. 1690. By H(anserd) K(nollys).     On line     PDF [88kb].

1692 - A Serious Answer To A Late Book Stiled, A Reply to Mr Robert Steed’s Epistle Concerning Singing Wherein The Chief Scriptures and Arguments are Examined, and the Weakness thereof Shewed. By William Kiffin, George Barrett, Robert Steed & Edward Man.     On line     PDF [195kb]